If you buy something through our posts, we may get a small commission. Read more here.

AOG VS Fire Magic: Our Expert’s Review of Two Popular Grill Brands

by Outdoor Cooking Pros October 27, 2020

AOG VS Fire Magic

Choosing the best grill for cooking can be quite tough since there are several underperforming brands in the market. Thankfully, our experts have tested some of the best grills and have come up with this AOG vs Fire Magic review to help you make the right decision. 


American Outdoor Grills, also known as AOG, is a brand that makes stylish and sturdy grills. They come in commercial-grade stainless steel constructions for increased resistance and durability.

AOG grills have outstanding features, such as high BTU, thermometer, stainless rod, halogen lights, etc. to make your cooking experience easy and worthwhile.

Fire Magic

Harold Keck founded fire Magic in 1937. The brand has been in the business for more than 75 years, making high-quality stand-alone and countertop gas grills ranging from 24" to 48" in size. 

Fire Magic also manufactures charcoal grills and several kitchen accessories. Their state of the art engineering technique ensures their products are high-grade, quality, and safe for users. 

This brand offers one of the best warranties in the industry. Their products, which are made in the US, come in 304 stainless steel designs and offer the best durability. 

Meat being grilled

So far, both brands offer an amazing line of grills that deliver optimal performance (just like Broilmaster and Weber, by the way). However, having tested both products, AOG is a better brand than Fire Magic for these reasons: 

AOG products are much easier to use. They come with intuitive controls and a user guide to make operating the machine convenient. 

Second, AOG offers more portable products than its counterpart.

More importantly, AOG grills and accessories come at a more affordable price than Fire Magic. 

With everything it offers, AOG is the clear winner in this comparison article. That said, here are some of the best AOG and Fire Magic grills we've cooked with. 

Top 3 AOG Grills

1. American Outdoor Grill 36PCT Portable 36” 3 Burner Gas Grill

American Outdoor Grill 36PCT Portable 36” 3 Burner Gas Grill

If you want a combination of portability and a fast heat up in a grill, you should consider AOG 36PCT Gas Grill.

What our team of experts loves about this model is its portability. Despite coming with unique features, this grill takes much less space than its counterparts.

It has three burners, with 12,000 BTU each for rapid cooking[1]. Also, it features the new piezo ignition system that lights up the burner rapidly, eliminating the need for batteries or electricity supply.

This grill comes with a vaporizer panel to distribute heat and a brass valve for accurate temperature control.


  • Easy to use
  • Highly portable
  • Rapid ignition system
  • Offers excellent durability


  • Slightly expensive
  • Pretty difficult to maintain

Check Today's Price


2. American Outdoor Grill 30NBL Built-in 30” 3 Burner Gas Grill

American Outdoor Grill 30NBL Built-in 30” 3 Burner Gas Grill

This is a top-notch, quality model from AOG in the new "L" series. AOG 30NBL comes in a 304 stainless steel construction for increased durability. It also delivers even heat distribution and minimal flare-ups through the vaporizer panels.

Instead of the piezo system, this grill uses the electronic push-button ignition system. With this, batteries will no longer be useful in igniting the burners.

Our experts love the inclusion of interior halogen lights in the grill, meaning you can choose to grill in the evening or at night.


  • Delivers even heat distribution
  • Includes halogen lights for night grilling
  • Offers durability
  • Wide grilling surface area
  • Easy to ignite


  • Quite heavy
  • Consumes space

Check Today's Price


3. American Outdoor Grill 24NBT Built-in 24” 2 Burner Gas Grill

 American Outdoor Grill 24NBT Built-in 24” 2 Burner Gas Grill

This AOG is an excellent burner gas grill that makes cooking faster and efficient.

It features an easy-to-use piezo ignition system, resulting in quick light up. With this, you will not need to use electricity or batteries. Also, the grill has a stainless steel vaporizer for equal heat distribution.

AOG 24NBT comes in a heavy-duty stainless steel construction that not only makes the model durable but quick to clean. 

The grill is easy-to-hold and has a 4-prong adjustable meat holder, warming rack, and analog thermometer to maximize efficiency.


  • Easy to use and clean
  • Portable and consumes less space
  • Offers excellent durability
  • Efficient cooking


  • Comes with two burners only
  • Doesn’t have a large cooking area

Check Today's Price


Top 3 Fire Magic Grills

1. Fire Magic Echelon Diamond E790I 36” Stainless Steel Built-in Gas Grill

Fire Magic Echelon Diamond E790I 36” Stainless Steel Built-in Gas Grill

When it comes to performance and convenience, only a few products do it like Echelon Diamond E790I gas grill.

It comes in a mid-sized cast stainless steel construction, a size perfect for outdoor activities.

Our experts love the versatility that this grill provides. You can cook, grill, and smoke simultaneously. Also, it comes with a magic view window, allowing you to monitor your cooking without removing the lid, thereby conserving heat.

The grill comes with three stainless burners for even and independent heating and 90,000 grilling surface BTUs.


  • Large grilling surface
  • Durable 304 stainless steel construction
  • Magic view window that offers a convenient viewing experience
  • Offers even heat distribution 


  • Takes fairly much space
  • Requires some maintenance

Check Today's Price


2. Fire Magic Aurora A830I 46” Stainless Steel Built-In Gas/Charcoal Grill

Fire Magic Aurora A830I 46” Stainless Steel Built-In Gas/Charcoal Grill

Aurora A830I is another excellent product in this Fire Magic vs AOG comparison with a unique design and superb engineering prowess.

This grill comes with seamless control that delivers optimal cooking capabilities, versatility, and comfort. Also, it comes in a stainless steel design for increased durability.

Our experts love the built-in gas/charcoal combo grill, which enhances its versatility. It has a large cooking space of combined 828 square inches, meaning you can cook and do your grilling simultaneously.

There is halogen lighting on the gas compartment, enabling you to make use of the grill at night.


  • Large cooking surface area
  • Gas/charcoal combo for increased versatility
  • Sturdy and long-lasting stainless steel design
  • Has halogen lights and LED controls for night grilling


  • Quite expensive
  • Slightly difficult to maintain

Check Today's Price


3. Fire Magic Echelon Diamond E1060I 48” Stainless Steel Built-In Gas Grill

Fire Magic Echelon Diamond E1060I 48” Stainless Steel Built-In Gas Grill

Echelon Diamond E1060I 48" is highly durable and helps to maximize users' outdoor grilling experience.

This model comes with four temperature zone displays to monitor the doneness of your food. With this product, you can set the temperature, observe your cooking time, and customize colors for your display.

The grill has flavor grids, surface ignition, and four stainless steel burners, totaling 112,000 BTUs for efficient heating. 

The large 1056-square inch surface area enables you to grill, cook, smoke your food at the same time. Overall, this gas grill offers optimal performance and convenience.


  • Multiple steel burners and flavor grids for effective heating
  • Cast stainless steel material for more durability
  • Large surface cooking area
  • Interior halogen lights for night time grilling


  • Ignites only through electricity
  • Quite costly

Check Today's Price


Overall Winner: AOG

AOG vs Fire Magic is one debate that has lasted for a while amongst grillers. Thankfully, our experts have put an end to it and have chosen AOG to be the better brand.

AOG grills are equipped with one of the best technologies around to make grilling super convenient for users. They all delivered nothing but excellent and consistent performances during hours of testing. 

Most importantly, all these outstanding models come at affordable prices. 

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.