Best Pizza Stone for Grill: Nine of Our Favorite Models (2021)
No, your pizza stone won't crack on the gas grill as long as you use it correctly.
Do it right on the best pizza stone and you'll get that nice crispy crust a baking sheet can only dream about.
Our experts agree that pizza stones are great. But there are so many choices out there. Don't worry, our reviews got you covered. Here are our tried and tested top picks for the best pizza stones for grill in 2021.
9 Top Pizza Stones for Grill
1. ROCKSHEAT Pizza Stone - Best Overall
Specifications
- Size: 15 x 0.67 inches
- Material: cordierite
- Available shapes: square, rectangular, round
- Weight: 7 pounds
Thoughtfully (and Beautifully) Designed
We saw to it that our top choice for pizza stones is not only functional but also convenient to use. Right off the bat? This stone doesn't require seasoning.
ROCKSHEAT's pizza stones also come with cleverly designed double-faced built-in handles. Don't they look good? Here are the reasons why we love this pizza stone for your grill:
- Not only do these built-in handles help save space but they are also practical. You can transfer pizza stones easier than ever (with the right protective equipment, of course).
- That said, you don't have to worry about accidentally dropping your pizza stone and losing your hard-earned money in the blink of an eye.
- Plus, you can store these pizza stones just like that. No need to buy additional racks that only take up space.
- The manufacturers also saw to it that their stones pack no unnecessary weight. That saves you long preheating times, unlike other stones. That doesn't mean this stone breaks easily though.
Pizzeria Quality Pizzas All the Time
Already got a ready-made pizza but the crust is just not crispy enough? Well, toss it on ROCKSHEAT's pizza stones and it will give you pizzas with a crispy crust you're craving.
ROCKSHEAT's cordierite pizza stones distribute heat evenly. It's not just about the crunch after all but also about that beautiful brown goodness you'd just have to take a picture of.
You'll get these results for many, many years as long as you use their stones properly.
Food Grade Safety
Craving something else aside from the smoky crust of pizzas? You can also bake quality cookies, bread, and biscuits on this stone.
You'll know it's safe for little kids because ROCKSHEAT's pizza stones were made in 2200℉ kilns. Any harmful substance has been heated right off even BEFORE they even put it in the box. There's no lead or any harmful stuff of the like.
The way these stones were made also gives them amazing heat capacity and thermal stability.
Want proof? See for yourself how this pizza stone comes out unscathed from a 1400℉ oven (for science). This stone can be used on a grill directly or as a heat deflector. It's certified oven safe and ready for the highest temperatures. Just don't use it in a microwave oven.
Pros
- Molded handles for easy transport
- Works well with all types of grills
- Lots of variety (shape, size, thickness)
Cons
- May stain with smoke
- Will get moldy if not dried after using
- Needs to be pre-heated to 500 degrees for 1 hour
2. Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan With Loop Handles - Best Value
Specifications
- Size: 18.43 x 14.75 x 1.25 inches
- Material: cast iron
- Available shape: round
- Weight: 9.55 pounds
Ready to Use, Can Be Used Anywhere
A hard-to-beat selling point of a metal pizza stone is the fact it's pre-seasoned. This cast iron pizza stone has been pre-seasoned with 100% natural vegetable oil. With this, vegans don't need to be concerned.
Do I even need pre-seasoning? We're about to drop a truth bomb on you and your home ovens.
While other pizza stones often get advertised as not needing seasoning, the truth is: they still need at least a pinch of cornmeal so pizzas don't stick to the surface once the heat comes.
Aside from that, this cast iron pan has large handles for better control. No need to use tongs or other tools.
Wherever safety is concerned...
- This pizza pan is ready and safe to use in a gas grill, on a stove, in the oven, or even over a campfire.
- Basically on anything that gives off heat.
- Works well with induction cooktops which are good for those living in condos that have strict requirements.
Established Brand and Loyal Fanbase
Get this pizza stone for grill if you want something proudly American-made. The quality won't disappoint you.
Lodge has had more than a hundred years of experience making high-quality cookware and accessories, all from the two foundries in South Pittsburg, Tennessee.
You can easily feel the quality of their pizza stone for yourself with the guaranteed even heating, natural easy-release finish, versatility, and durability. Lodge wants to make heirlooms you'll be proud to pass on to your children's children.
Pros
- Works well with ovens and grills (especially kamado types)
- Also good for fish, meat, and veggies
- Rim keeps fat and oils in
Cons
- A bit more expensive
- Needs careful maintenance (wash with mild soap at the most, prompt and thorough drying, and oiling while still warm)
- Only one shape available
3. BreadKings Pizza Stone - Budget Pick
Specifications:
- Size: 15 x 12 x 0.625 inches
- Material: cordierite
- Available shape: rectangular
- Weight: 6.6 pounds
No-Fuss Baking
BreadKing's rectangular pizza stone comes with an unbeatable price without crimping on quality.
It may be cheap but the temperatures this stone can withstand are just as impressive (up to 1,450°F!). You know this stone won't break easily before you get the pizzas you want.
It's got excellent thermal shock resistance and heat retention thanks to the cordierite stone, the same component that makes up more costly models.
Invisible micropores absorb excess moisture from the pizza dough. This way you can kiss goodbye the sogginess that often occurs with a lesser made stone for baking pizzas.
Even heat distribution? Check. Uniformly brown crisp crust? Check. Also works with bread, cookies, and biscuits? Check.
But what makes it one of the best pizza stones for grill is it works with either fresh or frozen pizza on either gas grills or a pizza oven. It will work with whatever you've got.
Pros
- Inexpensive
- Multipurpose
- Comes with a free multi-purpose plastic scraper
Cons
- Has browned butter odor
- Chips if not handled carefully
- Stains easily
4. CastElegance Thermarite Durable Pizza Stone for Crispy Crust
Specifications
- Size: 14 x 0.625 inches
- Material: cordierite
- Available shapes: rectangular, round
- Weight: 5.66 pounds
Trademark Thermarite Technology
Thermarite is a specially-formulated cordierite. It's made of clay and bits of metal like aluminum. (More on these materials in our buying guide section).
How thermarite differs though is it's engineered to be of higher density and durability. So you also get improved heat retention and thermal shock capabilities.
If you use this premium, professional-grade pizza stone in ovens or on grills (gas or a charcoal grill), you get pizza oven results at home for a fraction of the cost of one.
CastElegance did this by superheating Thermarite to over 2,000°F. You know this pizza stone won't just give. That superheating also saw to it that all organic matter has been vaporized. That's the secret to CastElegance pizza stones' odorless feature regardless of the heat.
Certified Safe
CastElegance put in the effort to get certifications to prove their high safety standards.
They've passed a number of international safety standards, including the US FDA, Restriction of Hazardous Substances (RoHS), European Union, and German Food Code.
Pros
- Works with refrigerated or frozen dough
- Comes with a 4″x5″ scraper, use and care instructions, and a recipe ebook
- Various size and shape options
Cons
- Acquires mold if not thoroughly dried
- Cumbersome drying requirements (requires 1 hour of baking on 500 degrees after each use)
5. Heritage Pizza Stone
Specifications
- Size: 15.79 x 2.48 inches
- Material: ceramic
- Available shapes: round, square
- Weight: 3.15 pounds
Heavy Duty But Lightweight
Unlike other heavy-duty ceramic pizza stones, Heritage pizza stone checks in at only half your expected weight.
How does this translate in real life? You get pre-heating times twice as fast as other stones. That doesn't mean your pizza won't be thoroughly cooked though. Not with this pizza stone for grill.
No soggy pizza bases here, only satisfyingly crispy crusts and solid centers.
Convenient to Use by Design
A tapered edge makes serving pizzas from this stone easy. Not only will you be cooking faster, you'll also be getting your pizza out of the oven and off the pizza stone faster.
Not only that, even cleaning will be a breeze because the burned bits slide right off those edges.
Protected Surface
Heritage pizza stone is cast from black ceramic and protected by a heat-resistant coating. Your oven won't damage this stone.
The specially added layer shields the surface from very high temperatures and prevents the pizza stone from smoking.
Our team noticed that's one of the most common complaints people have–that too much smoke from the grill or oven gets into the pizza and ruins the flavor.
Aside from helping with preventing your pizza from sticking, the added glaze on this baking stone also makes it grease and burn-resistant. With this, you won't leave as much mess in your oven or grill before.
Pros
- Comes with a pizza cutter
- Light and easy to handle
- Works well in an oven or grill
Cons
- Stone coating may flake off
- Stain carries over successive cooking
- Can't be used on all stove tops
6. Cuisinart CPS-445
Specifications
- Size: 13 x 2.56 inches
- Material: cordierite
- Available shape: round
- Weight: 5.98 pounds
Perfect Starter Set
Cuisinart's 3-Piece pizza stone for your grill gives you all your baking needs. With this stone, absolute beginners are very much welcome.
You'll get all the essential pizza tools in one box, including a 13-inch round pizza stone, a folding pizza peel, and a pizza cutter.
That folding pizza peel is a great bonus because it's so easy to store. A lot of buyers love that about CPS-445. The peel is also stainless so you know it's for keeps.
Like any cordierite pizza stone, this stone for grill has excellent heat retention and distribution. You'll get evenly cooked and perfectly crispy crust on your pizza with every session using this stone.
In 15 minutes, you'll be reaching for that pizza cutter and handing out slices to your excited customers. Who would have thought a grill and a stone could make such professional-looking pizzas?
Pros
- Includes a folding pizza peel and pizza cutter
- Reasonable price and size
- Seasoning not necessary
Cons
- Long pre-heating time
- Needs a good amount of cornmeal
- On the smaller end
7. CucinaPro Pizza Stone for Oven, Grill, BBQ
Specifications
- Size: 16 x 14 x 0.625 inches
- Material: clay
- Available shapes: rectangular, round
- Weight: 10.2 pounds
Largest Surface Area
Both the rectangular and round pizza stones CucinaPro makes are “XL.” Now you can make restaurant-quality (and quantity) pizzas, bread, pastries, and even vegetables.
So if you like fitting as much as you can when baking, then this pizza stone for grill is the one for you.
The same goes for those with bigger families or huge groups of friends. You can even buy more than one just to be sure.
Professional Grade Pizza Stone
CucinaPro Pizza Stone for Oven, Grill, and BBQ is made from the same materials used to line commercial baking ovens. But don't be misled.
CucinaPro's pizza stones were definitely designed for use on the grill, not just a brick oven. This pizza stone is porous enough to absorb moisture but solid enough to produce a crisp pizza crust—just like a traditional restaurant pizza oven!
Not only that, this pizza stone will season itself over time because of those tiny holes. So expect only better and better performance (and pizza crusts).
If those features haven't sold CucinaPro's pizza stones to you yet, their pizza stones are quick and easy to care for. Just wipe or scrape clean.
Overall, both amateur and professionals alike will find something to love about this pizza stone.
Pros
- 3/4 inch thick stone protects against breakage
- No maintenance required
- Works well either with an indoor oven or outside grill
Cons
- Too big for some grills (double-check size before buying)
- Comes with an odor on the first use
- Sometimes takes long to pre-heat
8. Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan
Specifications
- Size: 13.5 x 17 x 1.5 inches
- Material: cast iron
- Available shape: round
- Weight: 6.42 pounds
Durability That Won't Break the Bank
People look for cast iron when they want something sturdy; something that will survive tough wear and tear. They choose to invest in the robust pizza stone that keeps.
But who says you need to pay more to get more? Home-Complete successfully made cast-iron pizza stones for grill that doesn't hurt your wallet. Their pizza pan is just as resistant, long-lasting, handy, and multi-purpose.
Grilling Pizza Stone For All Moods
This 14-inch pizza stone can handle all sorts of food for all sorts of moods. Pizza, eggs, bacon, cornbread, biscuits, pancakes, crepes, fajitas, burgers, what have you.
We know you want pizza now but people's minds can change. Get this pan if you don't like to be boxed in.
You can even use this pizza stone in the oven, on the stovetop, on the grill, or even over a campfire flame! No need to worry about burning your breakfast (or lunch or dinner). This pan will reliably heat up evenly.
Pros
- Affordable
- Durable
- Multi-use
Cons
- Will grill pizza a little under 14 inches because of the lip
- Needs re-oiling and re-seasoning to prevent rusting
- Pebbly surface
9. NerdChef Steel Stone
Specifications:
- Size: 16 x 14.25 x .375 inches
- Material: alloy steel
- Available shape: rectangular
- Weight: 23 pounds
Fastest Bake Time Thanks to Unmatched Heat Conductivity
NerdChef promises a gorgeous crust with beautiful blistering and the fastest bake times if you use their pizza stone.
Their secret is the 20x faster heat transfer compared to ceramic stones, plus double heat capacity! It's just like having a 1000-degree wood-fired oven at half the temperature.
Craftsmanship That Spares No Expense
NerdChef's pizza stone has finger holes to make it much easier to move or hang on the wall. That's why they made this pizza stone this beautiful. In addition, this pizza stone is a tad heavy but it won't be hard to handle.
But what makes this pizza stone stand out? It’s the fact that it’s pre-seasoned:
- NerdChef had their pizza stones bead-blasted for that unique texture.
- Then they smoothly sand them by hand.
- After cleaning, they then apply thin layers of flaxseed oil and season them in an oven (no expense spared).
See the effort they put into crafting the best pizza stones? All it really needs now is a pizza.
They made it so you can just leave this pizza stone in your home oven. It's 100% made for the heat.
Pros
- Guaranteed unbreakable
- Can be used as a cold plate
- 3 thicknesses to choose from
Cons
- Expensive
- Heavy
- Requires maintenance like cast iron
Choosing the Best Pizza Stone for Grill: 4 Things You Should Know Before Buying
#1 Material
Most pizza stones you'll find are made of ceramic, cordierite, or some type of metal. You probably noticed that in our list as well. So let's quickly go over the good and the bad of each.
Ceramic
A ceramic pizza grilling stone performs well by reputation and tradition. It's an excellent material that's also cost-effective. After all, ceramic baking stones are easy to make, only created from clay baked in a kiln.
That said, you have to handle and maintain ceramic pizza stones properly because they crack more easily. But you can easily learn how to do that. And then your ceramic pizza grilling stone can last just as long as any other.
So if you are looking for a good but budget-friendly option, ceramic pizza stones are great choices.
Cordierite
Cordierite stone is basically a heavy-duty ceramic pizza stone. But it's also more than that.
Unlike ceramic, cordierite material contains bits of metal in them (like magnesium, iron, and aluminum).
This stone is the choice for those serious about cooking pizza, bake pizza often, or run a small pizza shop. Cordierite pizza stones were designed to take a fair amount of use without getting damaged in the process.
Metal
Metal pizza stones come in two types: cast iron and steel. Some like to think of them as a baking sheet except with more substance.
One thing they have in common is their need for a bit more care and maintenance.
That's the tradeoff for their guaranteed durability. You'd be hard-pressed to find a metal pizza stone for a grill that won't last you at least a few years.
Baking steel is the most expensive but is viable and can be easily subjected to high temperatures. It heats up and cooks faster for sure, which is why many people still choose to shell out money for one to use in their charcoal grill.
#2 Thickness, Weight, and Size
Let's just put it out there: A thinner pizza stone cracks and breaks more easily.
But a thinner pizza stone heats up faster than a thicker stone. So if reducing your cooking time really matters to you, you'd be happier buying a thinner stone.
But if you don't mind waiting for the best-tasting pizza, a thicker baking stone is more durable and will last you longer.
Thicker pizza stones, of course, also weigh more. This added weight explains the longer preheating time.
Lastly, factor in the overall size of your pizza stone. Don't only think about the pizza you'll be baking but also the size of your grill. Make sure your pizza stone for grill will actually fit your grill.
#3 Shape
A rectangular pizza stone hands down has a larger cooking surface area.
This pizza stone gives you more freedom. Say you want to bake a rectangular pizza or you want to bake something else entirely, maybe cookies or bread.
You'd definitely be able to fit more in a rectangular pizza stone.
A round pizza stone is perfect for people who don't have the space to spare. If your charcoal grill isn't the biggest option, definitely go for the round pizza stone. Plus, isn't it also indescribably pleasing to look at a round pizza on an equally round pizza stone?
#4 Heat Handling
Finally, how do you know if your pizza stone handles heat well? Just look up these three:
- Temperature Tolerance: how high the temperatures your pizza stone can reach
- Warm-Up Time: how long an oven/grill needs to heat up your pizza stone
- Heat Distribution: how evenly does your pizza stone heat up
You don't necessarily need a pizza stone with the highest temperature tolerance or even the shortest warm-up time. It all depends on your baking needs..
But you do want a pizza with the most even heat distribution.
(Need more help on the cooking? See how to grill pizzas here.)
FAQs
Do You Have to Season the Pizza Stone Before Using it on the Grill?
Most pizza stones don't require seasoning.
But if your pizza stone does need one, it's enough to rub a tablespoon of vegetable oil before baking. But do make sure this is actually recommended for your pizza stone.
The more common thing people do is pour a bit of cornmeal on top of the pizza stone once it's done preheating. You do this so you can smoothly position your pizza on the pizza stone.
Some people also use flour as they prefer. Either will prevent the dough from sticking to the pizza paddle.
How Do You Prepare a Pizza Stone?
The one thing you should remember is to never place a cold pizza stone into a hot oven or grill.
Doesn't matter what material your baking stones are made of. If you don't preheat, even the best pizza stone will crack, what is called a thermal shock.
Thermal shock happens when the pizza stone is exposed to sudden changes in temperatures. No pizza stone is so perfect to resist that, unfortunately. What happens is that different parts of the pizza stone expand as it heats up.
If this happens quickly enough (as when you don't pre-heat), you'll get the dreaded cracks on the surface (or worse, fractures).
Can You Use a Pizza Stone With Frozen Pizzas?
Short answer is yes, but you have to prepare the pizza.
It all goes back to thermal shock; you want to AVOID the sudden change in temperature. Putting a cold pizza stone in a hot grill is just the same as putting a frozen pizza on a hot pizza stone.
You can still use it on your pizza stone provided you let it thaw first. Either let it sit at room temperature for a few hours. Or throw it in a microwave to defrost for 10 minutes or so.
You can do this while pre-heating your pizza stones so no time is wasted.
How Do You Clean the Pizza Stone?
You only need warm water to clean your pizza stone. Don't even use any type of cleaning solution or dish detergent. Just soak the pizza stone in warm water when you're done baking.
Or if you feel better using a tool, you can also get a flat scraper or special BBQ brush. Just see to it that the one you buy doesn't scratch or damage the surface of your pizza stone.
If you see any residues, the natural heat from your gas grill will eventually burn it off. After that, you can just gently remove it with your hands.
Quick Recap
Pizza stones are not just for pizzas. If you love baking your own bread or other baked goods, you should definitely get one. Save yourself the trouble of finding out a baking sheet only gives subpar crusts and pizza centers.
How do you choose the best baking stone? Consider the material, dimensions, shape, and heat handling. Our quick buying guide has all the details you'll need to get that mouth-watering pizza crust.
So here again are the winners of our best pizza stone for grill list in case you forgot them already.
Best Overall - ROCKSHEAT Pizza Stone
ROCKSHEAT's cordierite pizza stone ticks all our boxes. It looks good. It's intelligently designed. And you get pizzeria-quality pizzas every single time, all without costing you a fortune. And, every baked goodie you get is guaranteed to be safe.
Best Value - Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan With Loop Handles
Lodge's cast iron pizza pan is ready-to-use and can be used on almost any cooking appliance. The microwave is always the odd one out when it comes to pizza stones.
That said, it's multi-purpose so you're not limited to grilling pizzas with this one. Lodge is also an established American brand with over a century's worth of loyal users. So you know it's worth every cent.
Budget Pick - BreadKings Pizza Stone
You get no-fuss baking with BreadKing's pizza stone.
This cordierite stone will get you there and will even last you a while if you care for it right. Plus the attractive price point doesn't hurt. They even tossed in a free scraper to help you get started.
Expand your grilling knowledge with more of our guides below:
Leave a comment
Comments will be approved before showing up.