If you buy something through our posts, we may get a small commission. Read more here.

More Than Just Steaks: Our Omaha Steaks Review

by Outdoor Cooking Pros July 08, 2021

Our Omaha Steaks Review

Whether you want to grill a steak or cook sous vide, going shopping for meat can be a nuisance. So if you need an online meat delivery service, this Omaha Steaks review will float your boat!

Our team went through their ordering process and even tried their food. Now we're telling you everything you need to know about them!



If you're looking for a smooth and efficient meat delivery service, we also highly recommend Butcherbox! They offer high quality meat with great value for money plus excellent service. 



An Introduction to Omaha Steaks

Omaha Steaks is one of the oldest companies in the business of full meat delivery.

The company came from humble beginnings, starting as a local butcher shop in downtown Omaha. Over generations, they've built themselves up and have now been in business for MORE than 100 years!

Imagine this: their first prime steaks in 1953 arrived via mail order! Kind of difficult to picture seeing how everything is mostly done online nowadays, right?

As technology progressed, so did the company. Now they’re one of the country's largest and best online meat delivery shops! See how Omaha Steaks compares to Butcherbox here.

The Omaha Steaks products now cover a wide range too! We'll cover that next. 

The Omaha Steaks Selection: More Than Just Meat

The first thing we noticed while ordering from them was the large variety of meats, cuts of meat, and other foods available.

You'd normally think of beef, pork, and chicken, but they even had sides, seafood, desserts, and wine!

Here are some notable items from their wide menu:

The Omaha Steaks Selection
  • Filet Mignon (learn how to grill filet mignon here)
  • Sirloin Steak
  • Strip Steak
  • Ribeye Steak
  • Wagyu Beef
  • Burgers
  • Pork Chops
  • Chicken Breast
  • Jumbo Franks
  • Fish Fillets
  • Cheesecake
  • Stuffed Baked Potatoes
  • French Fries
  • Cheesecakes
  • Dessert Wines

Meats We Chose for Our Omaha Steaks Review

With their selection being so wide, we chose to eat what we thought would deliver the ultimate satisfaction for us meat-lovers! We judged these meats according to quality and taste. (You might also want to check the best steaks for grilling before purchasing.)

Filet Mignon

This was an easy choice since filet mignons are some of the most tender cuts of meat you can buy. The only question is did the filet mignons deliver?

It did! The way they ship your package ensures your meat maintains its quality and freshness.

In terms of taste, it boils down to how it's cooked. The perfect steak can be easily wrecked by poor preparation and cooking.

So for our purchase, we made sure to season the steaks right (just the right touch of salt and pepper) and cooked it to our preferred doneness (medium rare is the way to go)! Biting into tender and juicy pieces of filet was so satisfying!

Pro Tip: One great way to cook a more than decent steak is temperature control via sous vide.

Bacon Wrapped Filet Mignons

Since we went with the filet mignon, we thought, "Why not kick it up a notch?"

So we did by ordering the bacon-wrapped ones! Omaha Steaks also ships these pieces of beef the same way so we were sure quality wasn't an issue.

Bacon Wrapped Filet Mignons

The preparation we followed was mostly the same too. Just season it right and cook it to your preferred doneness!

Having the properly prepared steak was already a nice treat the first time, but we found that biting into the piece of filet wrapped with crispy bacon was better! The tasty bacon added another dimension of texture and flavor!

Hint: The way it's packaged is also perfect to prepare via sous vide if that's what you want to go for. 

Omaha Steaks Burgers

Burgers are a classic food item, so of course, we wanted to see whether Omaha Steak burgers would do them justice.

Again, the way they package these things is just incredible. The beef arrived in such a way that its freshness and quality were still high, so it pretty much came down to preparing it properly.

Our approach to enjoying any good burger is similar to how we like our steaks, properly seasoned and grilled to our preferred doneness (a nice sear with the inside still juicy and tender).

As it turned out, even these were fantastic! The filets were tender, it was juicy, and the flavor of the beef oozed out with every bite!

Fresh or Frozen: How Your Omaha Steaks Arrive

Your Omaha Steaks meat products are always delivered frozen! That's the best way to retain the freshness! Each product is placed in a gift pack with dry ice before it's placed in a Styrofoam container[1].

Fresh or Frozen: How Your Omaha Steaks Arrive

The reasoning for this is it ensures the products remain cool throughout the day they're delivered to you! The dry ice is also enough to keep one or two orders frozen during shipping and for sous vide cooking.

However, some will ship theirs in polystyrene boxes since this insulates the ice better.

Pro Tip: Make sure to place the meat in a cooler or freezer as soon as you receive it.

How Omaha Steaks Does Shipping

Omaha sends emails to notify you about shipping. It's great since you know when to expect your entire order.

You can even select the optional phone alert which notifies you if the package has been delivered!

There's also a chance to score free shipping depending on your order! Avoiding shipping costs is a HUGE plus when it comes to online meat delivery service since it's often expensive.

Heads up though, ordering larger packages would obviously cost more. Thankfully, Omaha offers frequent discounts on their site!

Ever thought of giving steaks as a Christmas present?

They also offer a gift service that allows you to include a greeting card!

The Easy Ordering Process of Omaha Steaks

Their ordering process screams ease-of-use. The Omaha Steaks website is seamless! All you need are a few clicks to have your cart loaded up!

The Easy Ordering Process of Omaha Steaks

I received an order number for later review after checkout. It's quite convenient because they accept a variety of payment options too!

Ordering food via a mobile device also turned out to be just as easy! You'll have no problems ordering from Omaha Steaks if all you have to access the internet is your mobile device.

I'd like to point out that you have to pay attention to quantity throughout the process of ordering though.

Wondering why?

I’ve found that depending on the item, in some cases at least, it’s actually cheaper to order eight pieces than it is to order 4 pieces of the same item.

Is Their Customer Service Good?

It's decent! Their support team operates seven days a week. Customers need to make a phone call through their toll-free number!

Here's their schedule:

  • Weekdays - 7 am to 10 pm
  • Saturday - 8 am to 7 pm
  • Sunday - 9 am to 5 pm

They answer a lot of questions on their website fact center too! As for their support page, it's quite extensive. Overall, the experience of ordering for them is easy!

Omaha Steak Online Reviews: Are There Drawbacks?

Some users complained about small portions and how their products had poor quality.

But here's what you need to know:

  • Small portions are subjective. If the user DOES NOT know the cut they're getting, it's a disaster. People might order an 8 oz and expect a huge steak only to be disappointed. That's because 8 oz. is small! You want BIG? Go for a King Cut or between 24 to 45 oz.
  • After tasting their meat, it's ACTUALLY NOT poor quality. Some users mentioned it was poor quality, but really, this all boils down to HOW you prepare your meats.

Our Omaha Steaks Review Verdict

We had a decent experience ordering from Omaha Steaks! Here are some things I'd like to point out.

What We Liked

Overall, our experience was better than expected. What we liked most about it was:

  • The whole process of ordering was easy
  • Packaging and shipping were not an issue
  • The meal had solid quality and came in a good portion
  • It beats going to the grocery store!

Is Omaha Steaks Worth the Money?

It's a solid B+! Based on our experience, the food is priced at a reasonable value.

What you need to know is the cost of each cut varies greatly, but you can find meats like the best quality Wagyu steaks to lower-cost ones like ground beef.

Here are some examples of their pricing:

For Under $100

  • Omaha-cut Ribeye (4 pieces, 6 oz. per piece)
  • Wild Halibut Fillets (4 pieces, 6 oz. per piece)

For Under $50

  • Premium Ground Beef (2 packages, 1 lb. each)
  • Split Baby Back Pork Ribs (2 half racks)

Pro Tip: Proper Preparation Matters!

Another thing worth mentioning is that how you prepare your steak also plays a HUGE part!

Some complaints were about the declining standards of their products, but what we received turned out great.

Follow some of these tips and you're all set:

  • Place your steaks in the freezer or fridge as soon as they arrive!
  • Properly season them!
  • How you cook it plays a HUGE part!Hint: Try doing it sous vide.

Final Words

Omaha Steaks is a great choice for anyone looking for solid quality in their meat along with various selections to choose from. Most families would love the variety.

We reviewed more online meat delivery services for your convenience:

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.